When first confronted with the notion of âGood Cop/Bad Cop,â my screen-addled brain sputtered to a halt. Surely, this couldnât be a real television series. It checks out that a show with a forward-slash in the title is available to stream internationally on something called Stan., an Australian streaming service â which, yes, includes the period as part of its name â but itâs also been picked up in America on The CW? Are you sure? Did you check the one true source for release confirmations â the Metacritic TV premiere calendar? Isnât it more likely the police procedural about a brother/sister detective duo working for their dad/chief in a small Washington town was actually an old â30 Rockâ joke â something thatâs only stolen my attention today because Tina Feyâs prescient sitcom once again aligned with current events and took over social media?
But no. While the title does sound like the kind of show Josh would brag about landing before he eventually lost the gig to Frankie Muniz (remember Josh?), itâs a touch too generic to make it out of such a shrewd writersâ room. Their version wouldnât be âGood Cop/Bad Copâ; it would be the Tracy Jordan movie, âBlack Cop, White Cop,â complete with the tagline, âOne does the duty, the other gets the booty.â Thatâs funny because it sounds like a studio comedy (remember those?) that couldâve really been produced in the early 2000s, and because itâs clear the joke-tellers know how stupid their silly title sounds. âGood Cop/Bad Cop,â despite being real, doesnât show any such awareness.
Until, that is, you start watching. While far from the slyly subversive satire one might hope for given its bluntly brainless title, creator (and veteran sitcom writer) John Quaintanceâs hourlong police procedural is self-aware enough to make its flaws forgivable and its strengths unmistakable â most prominent among the latter is its effervescent star, Leighton Meester. (Someone please give her a plum, prominent lead part in a premium production, my god, why do I even have to ask?) âGood Cop/Bad Copâ is like if âBlue Bloodsâ was set in a town of 9,346 people, the number of cop-family protagonists was reduced to fit their fun-sized jurisdiction, and their biggest concern was running into an ex at the local diner. Itâs a silly-fun time (not a stupid-fun time), which helps the first six episodes settle somewhat uneasily on the side of âgood.â
Meester stars as Lou Hickman (short for Louise, which she disavows because itâs âan old lady nameâ), the top (and only) detective in Eden Vale, Washington. While some narcissistic cops may think having the whole department to themselves is a license to run wild, Lou is sick of it. Sheâs tired of handing off cases to the county sheriff because Eden Daleâs office doesnât have the resources for a proper investigation. Sheâs fed up with handling everything on her own, since the townâs recruiting pool for additional detectives is virtually nonexistant. Sheâs exhausted by the same boring tactics used to keep locals in line, like when she threatens to tell a suspectâs mother what heâs been up to because Lou knows her, personally. She knows everyone personally. Itâs a small town!
âI feel like KG when he played for the Wolves. Give me some complimentary pieces or trade me to the Celtics,â Lou says, immediately winning over this ride-or-die Boston basketball fan (despite relying on a sports reference thatâs nearly two decades old). Louâs passion for professional growth and preference for communal success over individual heroism are the initial endearing aspects of âGood Cop/Bad Copâ (if you donât count Meester herself, whose mere presence is an automatic plus), in no small part because Louâs not blaming her problems on where she lives. This isnât another story about a person trapped in their hometown, dreaming of what they could do in the big city, if only they could get there. Itâs a story about a young woman who wants whatâs best for her career because itâs also whatâs best for the people and place she cares about. Thatâs nice! Itâs also necessary, given the dire state of Americaâs rural communities.
Thankfully, âGood Cop/Bad Copâ doesnât dwell on such serious matters. Itâs not a serious show. Itâs a fun show, which sets its main story in motion when Louâs father/police captain Big Hank (Clancy Brown) answers his daughterâs pleas by bringing in another detective â someone who fits the budget, but still has experiences distinct to the existing team: Louâs brother, Henry (Luke Cook). Years ago, Henry left town after a minor dust-up with Big Hank and went to work in the nearest metropolis (Seattle) as a beat cop. But Henryâs lack of interpersonal skills are keeping him from the promotion he craves, so when presented with a chance to move up in the ranks, even one that means working for his father, he canât turn it down.

Henryâs awkward interpersonal interactions and obsessive behavioral patterns are both strange and familiar. Theyâre strange in the sense that his social skills are âworse than a serial killerâsâ and heâll only eat almonds while outdoors. But theyâre familiar because they fit a common TV archetype that often labels such characters as autistic, which this series has yet to do. âGood Cop/Bad Copâ doesnât want you to think Henryâs on the spectrum. It just wants you to think heâs weird. Could it have done so without inviting questions about his neurodiversity â questions like, âIs Eden Vale too small to support a proper psychologist who couldâve diagnosed Henry when he was a kid? Or did Big Hank simply never take him to the doctor? Does Big Hank not even believe in doctors? Wait, is this show set in a future where RFK Jrâs worm-brained health policies have forever warped our childrenâs futures? Is that the twist? Is this secretly a stupid-fun show after all?!â
No, itâs not. Itâs a silly-fun show that, like its small-town police force, doesnât have the resources to grapple with such weighty issues, so it does itâs best to avoid them. As Lou and Henry team up for new cases every week, âGood Cop/Bad Copâ overcomes its meager production budget by leaning on lighthearted vibes. Thereâs solid physical comedy, clever quips, and endearing family bonding â and Meester isnât the only actor capable of delivering them. Plus, the investigations are goofy! The first crime revolves around two unrelated burglars who show up to rob the same pharmacy at the same time. Another involves intimidating (but never hurting) a high school quarterback before his big rivalry game. Perhaps the best episode of the six screened for critics hinges on an amateur actress who goes missing while shooting a YouTube video. (âWell, itâs a YouTube video for now, but one day itâll be a movie,â the baby-faced director says.)
âGood Cop/Bad Copâ feels most at home when itâs awkwardly staged around the Hickmansâ dinner table â Lou and Henry sitting side by side, with Big Hank and his TV-obsessed girlfriend Nadia (Blazey Best) at either end. Not only does the awkward seating arrangement emphasize the showâs mandated ethos of economy over realism â itâs faster to shoot facing in one direction than two (let alone four) â but it also emphasizes how little I care that four people are inexplicably taking up three sides of a four-sided table. Sometimes TV just has to be charming enough, silly enough, and sound enough to earn your time. Sometimes it just needs committed actors, writers, and producers who know what to prioritize and what to disregard. Sometimes it just needs a character who canât stop bringing up real TV shows to show how much the people behind the one youâre watching love TV.
âGood Cop/Bad Copâ may be a terrible title, but itâs far from terrible show. Everyone making it appears to know it can surprise some people â keep those âTwin Peaksâ references coming, Nadia â and now I do, too.
Grade: B-
âGood Cop/Bad Copâ premieres Wednesday, February 19 at 9 p.m. ET on The CW.

